Last week I wrote the following (I “published” it – you may have received it before I deleted it, I could not get the formatting right!):
For many months I’ve been more and more uncomfortable with the decisions being made by NS Premier Tim Houston. I was not, I am not, a Houston supporter, but I was willing to give him an opportunity to “fix” health care, while believing it was difficult, if not impossible, given the complexity of the problems. There are other aspects of NS life also needing serious government decision-making besides health care – housing, for example, unban development, transportation, the economy, interprovincial trade…. The list goes on and on.
Nova Scotia is no different than other provinces. These are the problems facing every Canadian province and likely every US state! So it’s been interesting watching Houston as he “tackles” these problems. What’s become more and more worrisome is the secrecy, the lack of transparency, that’s becoming the norm over the decisions being made in my province. We’re also seeing executive overreach in some of the moves being made by Houston!
My concerns were confirmed today in an article by Michael MacDonald: ‘Control-mania’: Nova Scotia premier accused of executive overreach with new bill in the Canadian Press.
Attempts by governments to reduce public scrutiny and stifle criticism are becoming increasingly common, said Tom Urbaniak, a political science professor at Cape Breton University. “This populist movement that we’re seeing across the democratic world weakens institutions that can provide objective information in favour of spin and propaganda,” he said in an interview.
“We’re seeing a significant scaling back of the access to information regime in Nova Scotia,” he said. “It will make it much easier for the executive, the cabinet, to decide whether a request is too broad or frivolous or vexatious.”
Last week Houston refused to respond to questions from the press. He’s curtailed full debate of many issues in the legislature.
Slowly, but surely, in many small, often unnoticed ways, the pubic right to accurate information about decisions being made by our provincial government are being limited.
Our auditor general has called out the current Conservative government over a variety of spending decisions and indiscretions. Houston’s latest move has been to include a provision in a new omnibus bill that allows the firing of the auditor general without cause effectively undermining that important oversight should information detrimental or embarrassing to the government be made public!
“The ability to remove the auditor general without cause, combined with the ability to control our public reporting, impacts the independence, integrity and objectivity of the office,” Adair (our current auditor general) told a news conference.
“These changes could mean any report the government doesn’t like wouldn’t be made public.”
Such secrecy ensures the NS public doesn’t learn about what could be a growing number of questionable, perhaps detrimental, decisions this government is planning – we simply won’t know what’s really happening as our government moves forward.
This is how autocracy creeps up on us.
A few days ago pubic response forced Houston to rescind the bill which included unilaterally being able to get rid of the Auditor General without cause!
Today, in The Coast Daily, Julie, the editor echoes what’s been rattling around in my head!
Good morning Halifax,
The PC Party of Nova Scotia’s latest message to its supporters asking for money is bone-chilling—and if you were slightly concerned that this government is trying to uproot democracy, clearly your concerns are valid.
In a fundraising letter last week, MLA Leah Martin—obviously towing the party line—wrote to supporters:
“Will you pitch in here right now to help us withstand NDP attacks, overpower the special interests and professional protesters, bypass the media when we need to and stay on track with our plan to make it happen for Nova Scotia?”
Ummm, make what happen for Nova Scotia? Fascism?
This narrative that the media is the enemy is untrue, cowardly and a kick in the teeth to voters. Citizens have a right to know the policies and activities of their government, and the media has the right to ask tough questions about those policies and activities.
But premier Tim Houston has completely limited the media’s access to elected officials, allowing them to only answer questions during times organized by the government in a room they control across the street from the legislature. It gives big “we’re scared of scrums” energy to me—bitching out of the way politicians in Nova Scotia have answered questions for literally ever.
So, to review: This government was elected based on YOUR votes and now they want YOU to pay for them to ensure YOU don’t know what they’re doing.
I don’t know where Houston is getting his audacity. It can’t be from the confidence people have in him, because most people voted for nobody. It can’t be from feeling powerful, because his trips to meet with Trump’s underlings had zero impact on tariff decisions. It can’t be from feeling popular, because he had to walk back his auditor general bill after being so unanimously publicly criticized.
Where then? 🕵️
Hope your day makes more sense than all of this!
– Julie
I have no idea what I can do about this personally, except to copy this post and send it along to the premier! He needs to know people are watching and aren’t happy with his attempts to hide what he’s doing. He needs to understand the citizens of NS deserve to be informed about the basis for decisions he’s putting forth.
I sure don’t like how this is beginning to look – small potatoes in comparison to what’s going on in the US, but hints of Autocracy are here, nevertheless!
Feb 27 2025
I sent a note with a copy of this blog entry to The Honourable Tim Houston, last evening. I’ll eventually get a form reply. No guarantee any actual person will read the piece. JMN